Current:Home > ScamsEPA Finding on Fracking’s Water Pollution Disputed by Its Own Scientists-LoTradeCoin
EPA Finding on Fracking’s Water Pollution Disputed by Its Own Scientists
View Date:2024-12-23 20:45:16
An Environmental Protection Agency panel of independent scientific advisers has challenged core conclusions of a major study the agency issued in June that minimized the potential risks to drinking water from hydraulic fracturing.
The panel, known as the Science Advisory Board (SAB), particularly criticized the EPA’s central finding that fracking has not led to “to widespread, systemic impacts on drinking water resources in the United States.” The oil and gas industry has seized on the conclusion to argue that broad concerns about fracking’s impact on drinking water are overblown.
The SAB’s 30 members, from academia, industry and federal agencies, said this and other conclusions drawn in the executive summary were ambiguous or inconsistent “with the observations/data presented in the body of the report.”
“Of particular concern is the statement of no widespread, systemic impacts on drinking-water resources,” the SAB wrote in a preliminary report. “Neither the system of interest nor the definitions of widespread, systemic or impact are clear and it is not clear how this statement reflects the uncertainties and data limitations described in the Report’s chapters.”
The panel said that the EPA erred by not focusing more on the local consequences of hydraulic fracturing. “Potential impacts on drinking-water resources are site specific, and the importance of local impacts needs more emphasis in the Report. While national-level generalizations are desirable, these generalizations must be cautiously made…A conclusion made for one site may not apply to another site.”
The EPA also should have discussed in far greater depth its own investigations into residents’ complaints of water contamination in Dimock, Pa., Parker County, Texas and Pavillion, Wyo., the panel said. In each case, EPA scientists and consultants found early evidence of contamination but the agency ended the investigations before further monitoring or testing could be done.
The SAB’s assessment is part of the peer review of the nearly 1,000-page draft assessment issued by the EPA to address public fears about the possible effects of fracking on drinking water.
The SAB conducted meetings over several days in Washington, D.C. in late October to gather public comment on the EPA draft study. The SAB’s preliminary report for detailing its concerns was released in early November. It plans to continue discussion during a four-hour long teleconference on December 3. The panel lacks the authority to compel changes to the report and can only issue recommendations to the EPA.
Launched five years ago at the behest of Congress, the water study was supposed to provide critical information about the production method’s safety “so that the American people can be confident that their drinking water is pure and uncontaminated,” said a top EPA official at a 2011 hearing.
But the report was delayed repeatedly, largely because the EPA failed to nail down a key component: the prospective, or baseline, sampling of water before, during and after fracking. Such data would have allowed EPA researchers to gauge whether fracking affects water quality over time, and to provide best industry practices that protect drinking water.
EPA had planned to conduct such research, but its efforts were stymied by oil and gas companies’ unwillingness to allow EPA scientists to monitor their activities, and by an Obama White House unwilling to expend political capital to push the industry, an InsideClimate News report from March showed.
Still, the EPA report determined for the first time that fracking had fouled drinking water. The finding was a notable reversal for the Obama administration, which, like its predecessors, had long insisted that fracking did not pose a threat to drinking water.
The EPA report confirmed that there were “specific instances” when fracking “led to impacts on drinking water resources, including contamination of drinking water wells.”
The SAB plans to issue its draft recommendations in January 2016 and the final report in late spring, according to David Dzombak, the panel’s chairman and head of the department of civil and environmental engineering at Carnegie Mellon University. While the EPA is not obligated to act on the SAB’s recommendations, Dzombak said, the agency’s office usually sends a letter of response.
veryGood! (39)
Related
- US Open finalist Taylor Fritz talks League of Legends, why he hated tennis and how he copied Sampras
- Where are the best places to grab a coffee? Vote for your faves
- Man tied to suspected shooter in Tupac Shakur’s 1996 killing arrested in Las Vegas, AP sources say
- Dianne Feinstein remembered as a trailblazer and pioneer as tributes pour in after senator's death
- Seattle man faces 5 assault charges in random sidewalk stabbings
- Wyoming woman who set fire to state's only full-service abortion clinic gets 5 years in prison
- Ukraine hosts a defense industry forum seeking to ramp up weapons production for the war
- Fourth soldier from Bahrain dies of wounds after Yemen’s Houthi rebels attack troops on Saudi border
- Mike Tyson emerges as heavyweight champ among product pitchmen before Jake Paul fight
- MVP candidates Shohei Ohtani, Ronald Acuña Jr. top MLB jersey sales list
Ranking
- ‘Heretic’ and Hugh Grant debut with $11 million, but ‘Venom: The Last Dance’ tops box office again
- DOJ charges IRS consultant with allegedly leaking wealthy individuals' tax info
- Israeli soldiers kill a Palestinian man in West Bank, saying he threw explosives
- 6 migrants rescued from back of a refrigerated truck in France
- Judge set to rule on whether to scrap Trump’s conviction in hush money case
- 'Surreal': Michigan man wins $8.75 million in Lotto 47 state lottery game
- U2 concert uses stunning visuals to open massive Sphere venue in Las Vegas
- Former Kansas basketball player Arterio Morris remains enrolled at KU amid rape charge
Recommendation
-
Why Dolly Parton Is a Fan of Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce's Little Love Affair
-
Scott Hall becomes first Georgia RICO defendant in Trump election interference case to take plea deal
-
North Carolina radio station plans to reject broadcasts of 'inappropriate' Met operas
-
Checking in With Maddie Ziegler and the Rest of the Dance Moms Cast
-
'I know how to do math': New Red Lobster CEO says endless shrimp deal is not coming back
-
To prevent gun violence, these peacemakers start with the basics
-
Jessica Campbell, Kori Cheverie breaking barriers for female coaches in NHL
-
Wyoming woman who set fire to state's only full-service abortion clinic gets 5 years in prison